http://news.bostonherald.com/localRegional/view.bg?articleid=153054
Eight-year-old Hailey Manduca says she needs her loyal dog Independence in school to help her keep her balance.
But Scituate school officials are saying the dog doesn’t know how to behave himself in class.
School officials have barred the girl, who has a rare bone disorder, from bringing the service dog to school.
A lawyer for the School Department said yesterday officials don’t oppose the use of service dogs in schools, but claimed that Hailey’s yellow Labrador-golden retriever mix poses a potential safety and liability risk.
“A well-trained service dog can be a wonderful aid, but this dog presents a safety threat,” said Mary Ellen Sowyrda of the Quincy law firm of Murphy, Hesse, Toomey and Lehane.
Sowyrda said Independence barked and growled the few times she was allowed at Hatherly Elementary School over the past year.
But Hailey’s mother said the dog reacted that way only once, when a teacher she had never met before rushed forward to meet her.
“It startled Independence and my daughter,” said Cheryl Manduca. “The dog has never barked again at anybody.”
Manduca noted that in the year the family has had Independence, the dog has accompanied her daughter to church, to Girl Scout meetings, to the hospital and to Disney World – all without incident.
The family bought the dog last August at the recommendation of Hailey’s doctor, who said that her muscles were becoming weaker because of her reliance on a walker.
Hailey has osteogenesis imperfecta, a genetic disorder commonly known as brittle-bone disease that has caused her to break a bone 60 times.
“Every day with her is a miracle,” Cheryl Manduca said.
Hailey is already assigned an aide in school, but that has not prevented her from being hurt.
In June, she broke her leg after the aide stepped away to talk to someone and a boy pushed her, Manduca said.
“I’m scared to death to send her to school,” the girl’s mother said.
The dog helps Hailey keep her balance as she holds his harness. Independence also is trained to bark for help if Hailey falls, on her signal of squeezing her fingers.
This article pisses me off. Here’s a poor kid with a debilitating illness which more or less fucks her chance at a normal life. And she goes to a school district that is inhabited by morons who are worried that her service dog will somehow eat her fellow classmates or something lame like that. Instead of dealing with the issue and making her feel part of the class, they exclude her – which further alienates her.
Oh, and I’m pretty sure that the boy who pushed her and caused her to break more bones didn’t get in trouble at all because that is how moronic school districts work. “Let’s punish the helpless instead of protecting them.” Assholes.